HomeOutdoorMy Buddy and I Shot the Identical Report Bull...

My Buddy and I Shot the Identical Report Bull Elk


A very powerful bowhunting ability is the flexibility to get so near sport that the archer can nearly scent it. The bowhunter ought to hunt silently on a regular basis. I ignored that rule on September 12, 1970, and it price me an opportunity at an enormous bull elk.

Every little thing was in my favor. Wrinkled clouds hung over the japanese slope of the Rockies west of Fort Collins, Colorado. Early-morning dew made the bottom moist-perfect for noiseless strolling. A delicate breeze was blowing on my face as I eased right into a mountain drainage coated with lodgepole pines, aspens, and grassy meadows. It was acquainted territory. I had seen many elk there in earlier years.

I sneaked round downed timber and studied the forest for hours with my 7 x 35 Bausch & Lomb binoculars however noticed no sport, and I couldn’t discover any recent signal. I turned satisfied that no sport had used the basin for weeks. As a final resort I attempted bugling with my selfmade elk name. There was no reply. I concluded that my greatest wager was to stroll over a ridge and head down into one other basin in a close-by space.

I got here to a sport path among the many thick lodgepole pines on the slope. At one time it had been used closely, however now it was barren of tracks. Moments later I approached a big patch of blueberry bushes nestling within the timber above me. I thought-about glassing the bushes however determined that it was a waste of time and walked briskly forward.

A black and white photo of a hunter with a homemade elk call

All of a sudden I noticed one thing transferring within the blueberry patch, after which I made out the large antlers of a royal bull elk. The animal was mendacity down lower than 50 yards away. The motion I’d seen was the bull’s head turning towards the primary slight sound of my careless method.

Issues occurred so quick that I didn’t have time to nock an arrow. As quickly because the bull noticed me he exploded out of the bushes and bolted up the ridge. He didn’t dodge or run round something; he barreled over and thru no matter was in his means. Lifeless tree branches snapped with the sound of pistol pictures as his rack ripped via the pines.

I used to be disgusted with myself. After I jumped that bull out of his mattress, I used to be solely 22 years outdated. I had been searching with archery deal with for 9 years, and I hadn’t taken a single big-game animal, not even a deer.

I’m single and was born and raised in Fort Collins. Most individuals who develop up in that space develop outside pursuits at an early age. I loved all sorts of sports activities. I developed the standard curiosity in searching with firearms throughout my early faculty years, however I additionally wished to play soccer. By the point I entered Poudre Excessive College I had to decide on between soccer and firearms searching as a result of each are fall sports activities. I made a decision to stick with soccer. There could be loads of time for searching with a rifle after my highschool and faculty years had been over, I reasoned.

I then started attempting to attain on a deer or elk with a bow. The Colorado archery seasons usually open in mid-August, so I may spend per week or so within the mountains earlier than reporting for soccer. My first 4 years of bowhunting had been dismal failures. I typically hunted two or three days in a row with out even seeing a big-game animal.

About that point, a mutual buddy launched me to Ben Alexander. Ben, now 28, is married and has two babies. He works for a water-filter plant in Poudre Canyon, 20 miles west of Fort Collins. He grew up close by and was stuffed with mountain lore. After I first met Ben he was 22 and had a eager curiosity in bowhunting. He invited me to hunt with him, and I accepted eagerly.

That was the start of a friendship that has grown nearer via the years. The factor that intrigued me most about Ben was his agency willpower to take an actual trophy with an arrow. He readily admitted that the chances towards him had been heavy, however he figured he had some probability if he tried lengthy sufficient and bard sufficient. Ben had killed a number of nice mule-deer bucks with a rifle, in order that problem had paled for him. He felt strongly that the item of searching ought to be the game itself, not meat on the desk.

A bull hangs upside down

Ben figured that if he took a mean deer or elk with an arrow, his trying to find that species could be over for the season. Holding out for an distinctive trophy animal supplied extra actual sport, he reasoned. Most of all, he loved the problem of going after the perfect with a bow.

Through the first two years I hunted with Ben I wasn’t so trophy aware, however I quickly picked up his mind-set. That’s one motive neither of us made a bow kill till the 1970 season.

Although Ben and I had been unsuccessful for therefore a few years, it wasn’t as a result of we obtained no alternatives. We’re “choosy” about long-range pictures. We don’t like to attract an arrow except we will get inside 40 yards of an animal. As a result of we had been unwilling to take long-range pictures, we frequently spooked sport by attempting to get nearer, however we didn’t wound any sport.

And we spoiled some simple pictures too. As soon as, my companion stalked to inside 15 yards of a five-point elk. The bull heard the arrow rubbing towards the bow when Ben drew. On the immediate of launch the elk whirled and bolted. The broadhead missed.

Mule deer within the timber gave me my greatest possibilities. I as soon as obtained inside 30 yards of an enormous four-pointer. He was standing above me on a slope close to an aspen grove. I misjudged the steepness of the slope, and the arrow went over him.

One other time I stalked a five-pointer that was feeding alongside a sagebrush ridge. I closed the space to 25 yards and was getting ready to shoot once I spooked a doe I hadn’t seen. She made one soar, and the buck was in excessive gear. Nonetheless one other time I had a straightforward shot at an identical buck, however my arrow smashed into an aspen between me and the goal.

My hopes for 1070 had been jolted once I was drafted into the Military on February 3. I used to be working then on a grasp’s diploma in laptop science on the College of Arizona. Whereas I used to be in primary coaching at Fort Lewis, Washington, I used to be certain there could be no trying to find me that fall. Then, by a stroke of luck, I used to be assigned to the Division Knowledge Heart at Fort Carson, Colorado. My outlook was brightened much more once I realized that I may take a 20-day depart in September.

The 1970 Colorado archery season for deer and elk ran from August 15 via 3eptember 20 ( the dates had been completely different for 1971), so I scheduled my depart to start on September 1. When that date arrived I hurried dwelling, purchased my searching licenses, and packed my gear. Colorado residents pay $7.50 for an archery deer license and $10 for an archery-elk license. The nonresident pays $25 every for comparable licenses.

Ben and I often hunt two areas about an hour’s drive west of Fort Collins. One space is sweet for each mule deer and elk. Within the different there are extra elk however fewer deer. Whereas discussing the scenario with Ben I made a decision to hunt the higher deer space in the course of the first half of my depart. Ben couldn’t get off from work to affix me for about two weeks. and I knew that he was primarily in searching elk within the second space.

“I’ll drive my tenting trailer in there on September eleventh,” he mentioned, “however I can’t begin searching until the thirteenth. You may base on the trailer and scout for a few days earlier than I be part of you.”

We mentioned the small print, after which I headed out. I drove so far as I may up an outdated logging street to an enormous watershed on the 9,500-foot elevation. It stretches northward for miles and is roofed by lodgepole pines, aspens, Douglas firs, and grassy meadows. My plan was to be out at daybreak every day, hunt till darkish, after which return to my automobile and sleep there.

The farther I went, the extra signal I noticed. One pine was rubbed naked of bark from the bottom as much as about 11 ft. That rub was a lot increased than any I’d ever seen earlier than. The bull that had made it needed to be an enormous.

After per week of searching I used to be nonetheless in search of my first shot of the season. I wasn’t discouraged — the climate had been excellent, and I’d seen 21 deer and eight elk. Not one of many animals wore antlers. however I’d had a number of enjoyable making follow stalks. I obtained inside 15 ft of 1 deer, and I managed to get inside 20 yards of an elk.

On September 8, I drove to Ben’s dwelling to verify his schedule was nonetheless the identical. Then I put in three extra days of uneventful searching. Late that final night I loaded my gear into my and drove 15 miles to the place my companion had mentioned he’d park his trailer. The snug unit was a welcome sight. Ben had made the physique himself out of aluminum siding. The trailer is eight ft excessive, 17 ft lengthy, and eight ft vast. It’s geared up with two sleeping couches, a desk, a fuel range, a lantern, and a fridge.

The following morning I started scouting our elk-hunting territory. It’s a bowl-shaped drainage eight miles lengthy by 4 miles vast. Ben and I had at all times discovered elk someplace within the drainage each time we hunted there. As a rule, we had discovered a herd in a single small basin inside the large bowl. Positive sufficient, that’s the place I spooked the bedded elk, as I described earlier.

After blowing my probability on the royal bull, I resolved to hunt as cautiously as potential. I’d transfer alongside as quietly as I may for about 10 yards after which glass the terrain round me. That’s my standard methodology in heavy timber. In thick cowl it’s nearly unattainable to identify sport earlier than it sees you-unless you glass greater than you progress. The virtually fixed use of binoculars tires the eyes, nevertheless it’s price it.

For a number of hours I continued my gradual, cautious hunt, however then I made a decision to maneuver a bit sooner since my major goal was scouting. It was late afternoon by the point I reached the southeast finish of the drainage, 5 miles from the trailer.

That’s once I started to identify recent elk tracks and droppings in a big stand of lodgepole pines and Douglas firs. The farther I went, the extra signal I noticed. Many timber bore current rub marks. A kind of antler rubs astounded me. The pine was rubbed naked of bark from the bottom as much as about 11 ft. That rub was a lot increased than any I’d ever seen earlier than. The bull that had made it needed to be an enormous.

I used to be so entranced by my discoveries that I didn’t pay a lot heed to a constructing storm, however as quickly as rain started pelting down I headed out in a rush. Then the temperature plummeted, and the rain modified to sleet pushed by a excessive wind. It was lengthy after darkish when I discovered the trailer. I used to be soaked via, and my garments had been half frozen.

The following day I hunted close to the trailer since I didn’t wish to disturb the herd earlier than my companion’s arrival. Ben arrived within the night and listened to my information with rising pleasure.

“They’re means again on the fringe of the bowl,” I defined, “too far-off to hunt full days from the trailer. Our greatest wager is to backpack in and keep close to the herd.”

The following morning we loaded our backpacks with tenting gear which may shock many hunters. Our gear is chosen on the speculation that the quickest option to spook sport is to promote your presence with human scent or noise. We camp chilly. In different phrases we by no means mild a hearth for cooking or heat. We pack in canned lunchmeats, fruit, and different ready-to-eat gadgets.

Chilly tenting could also be uncomfortable, nevertheless it eliminates the disturbances of woodchopping, cooking, and different camp chores. A bowman often has to get inside 40 or 50 yards of his quarry, and that’s nearly unattainable if his garments carry the odors of smoke or cooked meals. Getting inside certain bow vary is very unbelievable if the sport has already been alerted by the distant sounds of human exercise. Although we may have pushed near our vacation spot in Ben’s four-wheel-drive car, we didn’t even contemplate it, due to the noise issue.

Throughout our hike to the far fringe of the drainage a moist snowstorm lowered the visibility to close zero. We had been nearly to the tenting web site I had chosen when an unseen elk crashed out of a grove of pines forward of us.

“I informed you they had been in right here,” I informed Ben gleefully.

An hour later my two-man nylon pup tent was stretched between timber close to the sting of some pines bordering a small meadow. A meandering creek flowed behind our camp. We had been in a great spot.

A hunter with a record book bull in a truck

It was early night by the point we’d completed consuming and readying our archery gear. My bow has a 53-pound pull; Ben prefers a 48-pound pull. We use bow quivers and arrows tipped with four-edged heads. We purchase aluminum shafts and placed on the fletching and heads ourselves.

Our warning paid off that very same night. We had been lower than a quarter-mile from the tent once I bugled for the primary time. The high-pitched notes had barely died when an answering problem got here from throughout the basin. Once more I bugled, and once more the problem was returned, nearer this time.

After a number of extra exchanges, Ben and I knew the bull was coming quick. Quickly we heard his gurgling grunts within the timber throughout a 200-yard-widc meadow.

Then the bull obtained cautious. For an hour he answered my bugling invites to combat, however he wouldn’t come nearer. Daylight was fading, and it was too late to make a stalk.

Ben and I separated and bugled from varied spots alongside the sting of the timber on our aspect of the meadow. The bull moved backwards and forwards reverse us, however he nonetheless wouldn’t present himself. Then darkness fell, and we had been pressured to surrender the sport.

Learn Subsequent: The Greatest Elk Looking Rifles, Examined and Reviewed

As we walked again towards the tent alongside the sting of the meadow, I gave one final whistle on my name as a parting salute. We had been astonished when the bull answered from instantly throughout the meadow. He was listening to our actions and following us on a parallel route.

A number of occasions that night time we had been woke up by ringing bugles in close by timber. It was nearly unattainable to sleep with a bull elk so shut.

My companion and I had been up earlier than daybreak. Stars glowed, frost coated our archery deal with, and our camouflage garments had been frozen stiff. With barely sufficient mild to see, we studied the tracks the bull had made in snow the night time earlier than. Ben is generally very calm, however now he may hardly include his pleasure.

“I’ve by no means seen elk tracks that enormous,” he mentioned. “He’s an actual trophy bull.”

A black and white photo of a vintage hunter with a nice bull elk rack

We hunted exhausting all day with out success. We heard a couple of distant bugles however by no means obtained shut. A heat solar melted the remaining patches of snow, however by late afternoon a cloudy, chilly dampness settled into the bowl.

We returned to the tent, ready some meals, and had been adjusting our elk calls once we heard a faint bugle on the closest ridge. We didn’t pay a lot consideration — till the bellowing whistle sounded once more. That point it was so shut that we scram bled for our bows.

The bull was grunting up a storm. We heard brush snapping and guessed that he was simply contained in the pines and firs on the opposite aspect of the meadow in entrance of our tent. We needed to get throughout the opening and into the timber earlier than the elk reached the meadow. We may have made it simply by operating, however the bull would have heard us. Quietly however as quick as potential, we started to cross the meadow. Midway throughout, Ben slammed to a halt. I finished beside him.

“Look,” he whispered, “I see his legs beneath the branches. He’s coming straight at us!”

Then I noticed the bull’s legs transferring right into a dense clump of pines instantly in entrance of us. We nocked arrows, positioned our bows in entrance of our our bodies in order that we may shoot with as little movement as potential, after which froze. There was no cowl within the meadow. Our solely hope was to face immobile the place we had been.

I don’t recall seeing the bull emerge from the pines. All of a sudden he was there, standing broadside to us solely 30 yards away, fully out within the clear. His nice rack was held excessive, and his physique appeared swollen with overbearing satisfaction. His vanity and eagerness to combat a rival bull so absorbed him that he didn’t appear to note us.

I don’t recall seeing the bull emerge from the pines. All of a sudden he was there, standing broadside to us solely 30 yards away, fully out within the clear. His nice rack was held excessive, and his physique appeared swollen with overbearing satisfaction.

Ben and I drew on the similar immediate, however my arrow flew a split-second sooner than Ben’s. The bull heard the twangs of the bowstrings and snapped his head towards us. Immediately his physique appeared to shrink and cower in worry. His eyes bulged with obvious disbelief. As he lunged to his left I noticed {that a} light-colored arrow had pushed via his higher again. The shaft was plainly seen on all sides of the animal. I knew it was Ben’s arrow as a result of mine was noticed with camouflage paint.

The bull vanished shortly, however we may hear him crashing via the timber, and his operating retreat sounded uncontrolled. In seconds the commotion ceased. We figured the bull was down, however we waited 45 minutes earlier than following the blood-sprinkled path, wanting him to stiffen if he was solely wounded. We discovered the bull lifeless simply 90 yards from the place he’d stood when our arrows had sliced into him.

Skinning a bull in a vintage black and white photo

Once we field-dressed the bull we found that both arrow would have killed him. Mine had damaged a rib and made a gaping lower via the liver. The profuse inner bleeding had downed the elk after solely a brief run. Ben’s broadhead had lower via the bull’s spine simply above the spinal wire. If the arrow had been an inch decrease it could have dropped the trophy bull in his tracks.

These details led to a query: who ought to legally declare the bull? State legislation requires hunters to tag elk proper after the kill. There might need been some problem if Ben and I hadn’t been such shut buddies. We had been effectively conscious that the huge antlers would win some recognition.

Lastly we determined that I ought to tag the elk since my shot was positioned slightly higher than Ben’s and had brought on fast demise. And but I’m satisfied that Ben held his draw for a second in order that I’d have the primary shot. He’s the form of man who would do a factor like that and by no means admit it. By the point we completed the field-dressing chores a thick fog had blanketed the basin, so we determined to remain one other night time in camp. The following morning we marked a route from the bull to an outdated logging street by hanging small blaze-orange trail-marking ribbons on branches.

Then we hiked again to the trailer and drove Ben’s automobile to the house of his mother and father. His dad, Herb Alexander, a lifelong firearms hunter, was enthralled by our story.

“Nicely,” he mentioned with a smile, “I didn’t assume you fellows would ever get a bull with these sticks. In case your discuss is as large as you say, I can’t wait to see him.”

A bull elk in a vingtage pick up

Herb, Ben’s spouse Marion, and my brother Jim went with us in Herb’s jeep to assist load the animal. Herb’s car is rigged with a winch-and-pulley association that made quick work of the job.

After a 60-day drying-out interval the antlers had been formally scored for the Pope and Younger Membership by Marvin Clyncke of Boulder, Colorado. The principle beams measured 46 4/8 inches and 48 6/8 inches. There are eight factors on the suitable antler and 7 on the left, and the tip-to-tip measurement is 45 2/8 inches. The official rating is 364 2/8.

Learn Subsequent: The Greatest Compound Bows, Examined and Reviewed

As I write this story that rating is sweet for No. 3 rank within the Yellowstone-elk class of the Pope and Younger Membership’s information of North American large sport taken with archery deal with. The world file bowkilled elk scored 376 6/8. It was taken by Jack Sheppard in Idaho. D. A. (Bud) Johnson’s No. 2 bow-killed elk scored 366 5/8 and was additionally killed in Idaho.

Ben and I scored on the most effective trophy elk ever taken in Colorado with archery deal with. Our kill has been entered within the Pope and Younger Membership information beneath each our names.

Editor’s Observe: Although such a joint entry is uncommon, it does have a precedent. In 1958 searching companions Dr. James Rumbaugh and John Ruyan fired their rifles concurrently and dropped an enormous typical-whitetail buck in Ohio. Their trophy received first award in its class within the 1958-59 Boone and Crockett Membership competitors. The names of each males are collectively listed within the file e-book. The story of their hunt was informed within the November 1960 concern of Out of doors Life in “How I Received No. l Deer.”


This story, “Trophy for Two,” first appeared within the January 1972 concern of Out of doors Life. The present archery world-record for a typical American elk is 430 0/8 inches. That bull was killed by Montana bowhunter Stephen Felix in 2016.